I’m taking Grassley at face value. He has drawn “a line in the sand” before and changed it once. If he doesn’t make good on the 10 am EDT deadline tomorrow - I’m giving up on him.
Grassley’s sole objective should be to get the nomination out of committee and onto to Senate floor.
Collins is not on the Senate Judiciary Committee - she doesn’t get a say. Grassley does control the situation in getting the nomination out of the subcommittee’s hands. As I mentioned earlier Flake can vote to abstain ; it would be a tie at that point until VP Pence votes to forward the nomination to the full Senate. (Pence can cast a deciding vote in the case of a subcommittee tie according to the rules of the subcommittee). Flake can vote against him and that would kill his nomination - I think that’s the chance Grassley should take. Flake is either going to support Trump’s nomination or he’s not - further delay isn’t going to change that situation.Grassley is not calling the shots. Flake and Collins are.
Collins is not on the Senate Judiciary Committee - she doesn’t get a say. Grassley does control the situation in getting the nomination out of the subcommittee’s hands. As I mentioned earlier Flake can vote against him; it would be a tie at that point until VP Pence votes to forward the nomination to the full Senate. (Pence can cast a deciding vote in the case of a subcommittee tie according to the rules of the subcommittee).
So, yes it is Grassley calling the shots (IF he has enough backbone to do so).
The committee doesn't really kill a nomination, they can only make a recommendation to the full senate. It's just that the senate rarely goes against a committee's recommendation.
Once the subcommittee votes, the die is cast. The nomination either leaves the subcommittee or it doesn’t. The only senator who has shown any indication of being a “swing vote” is Flake. And I’m saying Grassley should call him on it.
Again, Grassley has the power to end this circus. He should do so. The political fall out and repercussions are much harder to bare in the full senate. Let them decide - by most accounts, Kavanaugh has enough votes to win in the full senate.