Join TexasGunTalk

Florida Man (here we go...)

Discussion in 'News Articles' started by busykngt, Aug 18, 2019.

  1. Bithabus

    Bithabus ! TGT Supporter

    Aug 17, 2010
    Shooter yells at victim's gf, victim shoves shooter, shooter falls down and draws pistol, victim stands and stares at shooter without advancing, shooter fires. I don't see any way this could be a justified use of deadly force.

    Frank59 likes this.
  2. Sublime

    Sublime Active Member

    Mar 24, 2019
    Generally no but here again is that simply what we have?
    Is a punch to the face deadly force? Generally no and yet people have died from it.
    Should the shooter have waited until being attacked again to fire? It's not, - he did this so I did that out there in the street. Sure we train in if/then thinking but our training is lacking when we put it to the test in the real world.
    It is unfortunate what happened but maybe people should stop being a..holes in the world. I'm sure the shootee didn't think he was gonna draw his last breath that day because his baby's mama illegally parked......but it was. Maybe he should have come out of the store said - I'm sorry, you are right, let me move it but his ego would not allow for that. Do you go around pushing older and weaker people to the ground because you disagree with them? He made it a fight and he lost.
    Last edited: Aug 19, 2019
    sdismukes and Sam7sf like this.
  3. Bithabus

    Bithabus ! TGT Supporter

    Aug 17, 2010
    But, he didnt get punched in the face.
    Most likely, since IMO he will be convicted
    This is correct but thought experiments like this can prepare us for the real event. Maybe if the shooter ran more scenarios through his mind he wouldn't have fired from anger/adrenaline and wouldnt be on trial now
    I agree
    Sam7sf likes this.
  4. ZX9RCAM

    ZX9RCAM Over the Rainbow bridge... TGT Supporter

    May 14, 2008
    The Woodlands, Tx.
    I'm guessing the dead guy didn't hear much of what was said before he got involved.

    He reacted to a guy yelling at his woman.

    And no, I'm not saying he should have pushed the shooter.
  5. candcallen

    candcallen Well-Known

    Jul 23, 2011
    Little Elm
    Consider that people have died from being pushed to the ground. Is it deadly force? Then consider the disparity in force question. Does that make a difference? How about the difference in age physical condition and how it effects these decisions.

    There is enough issues here for an easy hung jury or acquittal depending on the lawyer and money infolved.

    The old guy was a bastard but DID NOTHING to justify the younger guys escalation to physical force. Being a crotchety bastard running your mouth does not justify a physical force response. The young guy was going to continue the assault while the old guy was down till he saw the gun. That is where this case will rest. Does the jury think the assault clearly ended thus ending the threat? A good lawyer and expert will probably educate jurors on self defense concepts relevant to this case.

    IMHO it's a crap shoot, no pun intended. Public defender with no self defense experience or resources and this ends up in a conviction. That's not the case here so who knows.

    As for the disabled parking issue people should mind their own buisness. Pretty crappy to kill or get killed of such stupidity.

    I'm disabled have plates and placard and still get yelled at by others who dont see it or think I dont look disabled enough. I dont stop to converse and depending on the level of ars hole I am feeling usually tell them to pull their head out or go self fornicate as they dont know what they are talking about and move on. I never stop to argue with them beyond that. It ain't worth the confrontation.

    Beyond that my pet peeve is the disabled person driving their clearly not disabled friend and relative and takes up a spot then WAITS IN THE PHUKING CAR while the other person goes in. Followed closely by the person that will cut you off or race and damn near cause a wreck to get a space. Dont get me started on the supposed disabled person who takes up a spot at their place of employment while they work all day on their feet. I have to remind me self to mind my own buisness.

    I dont know about texas but in AZ we have specially trained and legally certified volunteers who do nothing but disabled parking Enforcement. You want to see some blood sport watch a couple old folks argue over a ticket and weather it's legal etc. Its funny till they have their license and registration suspended cause they tore up the ticket. It costs them over a grand to get legal again. All they would have had to do was show their placard to get it dismissed or lowered to a small court costs fine
    rmantoo, Sublime and Sam7sf like this.
  6. AustinN4

    AustinN4 TGT Addict

    Nov 27, 2013
    Thank goodness! Otherwise, a lot of us here would be in trouble.
    rmantoo, oldag, TxStetson and 2 others like this.
  7. busykngt

    busykngt TGT Addict

    Jun 14, 2011
    Personally, I’m in agreement with candcallen. I think it may not be nearly as ‘cut & dried’ as some think. I suspect the Florida SYG rule will be legally and throughly dissected - nine ways to Sunday!

    AND I believe it’s a pretty safe bet, the outcome may well depend on, how competent his defense attorneys are (read: $$+$). “If the glove don’t fit; you must acquit.” The verdict must be unanimous (albeit, only among six jurors). All I know is, if it were me on trial, I’d be wanting Sublime on MY jury!

    As candcallen said, “IMHO, it’s a crap shoot”. We’ll know in a few weeks. In any case, it’s a helluva way to spend a s-load of money you ain’t got. Especially when the alternative was, to simply mind your own business!
    Last edited: Aug 19, 2019
    TxStetson and toddnjoyce like this.
  8. sdismukes

    sdismukes Bending nails and making sawdust

    Nov 26, 2014
    Erath County
    In Texas, I know it’s FL, but in Texas words are not enough to start a confrontation.
    rmantoo likes this.
  9. Mowingmaniac 24/7

    Mowingmaniac 24/7 TGT Addict

    Nov 7, 2015
    ..." in Texas words are not enough to start a confrontation."

    You're kidding, right?
  10. Sublime

    Sublime Active Member

    Mar 24, 2019
    Well he probably meant - words don't justify a physical altercation (generally I would agree with that). You're on a roll tonight. Whacha drinking?

Share This Page