I'm pretty fed up with semi-autos. Which pump gun to buy for HD?

breakingcontact

TGT Addict
Oct 16, 2012
18,315
38
Indianapolis
I'm leaning heavily towards a Mossberg 590A1.

I've had 2 Mossberg 930's now. Sometimes they would be reliable, then they wouldn't be and I'd have to replace, polish or tweak another part. I was getting close to Benelli money in what I've put into these, so I'm pretty turned off on the semi-autos. Even the FN, Benelli, Berettas seem to not run everything consistently. I'll welcome your admonishment for giving up on the semi-auto guns. I know they have their advantages.

Yes, I know most cheap pump actions are good enough.

So, two questions on this...what other pump shotguns should I consider aside from the 500/590/590A1? (not interested in Remington)

Secondly, if I do go with the 590A1, I know the 5+1 version would be lighter and handier, but since shotguns are so limited in capacity, I am interested in the 8+1 version. What's your input on this?
 

Dawico

Uncoiled
Lifetime Member
Oct 15, 2009
34,265
113
Lampasas, Texas
The Benelli Nova Tactical is a great choice. You can add mag extensions as you see fit as opposed to the Mossbergs. Plus there are many factory options like pistol grip or standard or ghost ring sights or rifle sights. The camo version looks like something my daughter did but it has it's own beauty I guess.

The pump also has a button that will hold the rounds in the tube (not feed a round) so you can throw a different round in the chamber if you need to change types.

They don't cost much more than the 590s either.
 

M. Sage

TGT Addict
Jan 21, 2009
16,326
36
San Antonio
Pumps suck as bad or worse. IMO the 930 isn't a very good shotgun, though. Got to at least step up to an 1100 or SLP to get a halfway decent semi auto shotgun.

Maverick? He's trying to get away from cheap POS guns...
 

txbikerman

TGT Addict
Jul 10, 2013
5,966
36
mckinney
Been shooting pump shotguns for 30 years. Nothing wrong with them. after a while, you dont even think about racking the action. it just becomes natural.
 

benenglish

Just Another Boomer
Staff member
Moderator
Lifetime Member
Admin
Nov 22, 2011
14,984
113
Spring

TreyG-20

TGT Addict
Dec 16, 2011
3,762
113
Central
Maverick is cheap, but why is it a POS? I guess someone forgot to mention that to mine and everyone else who I know have them.
 

Sugar Land

TGT Addict
TGT Supporter
Apr 7, 2012
11,831
38
Sugar Land Texas
My saiga12 runs drum mag dumps over and over again. Don't give up on SA
 
Top Bottom