mini-14 or a ar-15


TGT Addict
Feb 7, 2009
Round Rock
Trying to figure out if I want a mini-14 or a ar-15. The mini 14 I want is just the basic ranch rifle(wood stock, blued barrel). The ar-15 I want to build is like the m16a1. I cant afford both, its one or the other. :banghead:


Active Member
Mar 15, 2009
Central Texas
country boy, I have both. And while I am partial to the AR from the get-go, I'll let you know why......My experiance with the AR is proven over many years and thousands of rounds down range. Very accurate, and simple to use. Lots of extras are available, from many suppliers. The Ruger, not so much. My Ruger has acceptable accuracy (although I've only fired it out to 100 yds. so far) The caliber is the same so no difference there. My issue with the Ruger is that it just seems "cheap" the action feels "loose", the ops rod rattles, the fit on the stock is poor, the finish is OK,not great, my biggest problem though, is that if the bolt is locked to the rear, and you bump the stock on the ground, the bolt goes home.... at first I thought I had not locked it correctly. But after doing it several more times, figured out it was the design, not the operator. Also extra mags are more expensive than the AR. And if you want to put optics on it (the Ruger) it ejects out the top, so you need a off-center mount. SO just a few things off the top of my head. Good luck! MG


Jun 28, 2009
Houston, Texas
I have both. The Mini-14 is fun and fine if all you want is a handy, fairly rugged little .223. But, as pointed out in the responses above, there really is no comparison with the AR-15. The AR-15 is capable of MOA accuracy or better depending on the barrel and upper and ammo used. You have a ton of options on the AR, including after-market trigger, a dedicated .22LR upper or the Ciener unit or similar to practice with cheap .22. No comparison in my opinion and experience.


TGT Addict
May 29, 2017
Austin, TX
The AR15 is the small block Chevy of the semi-auto world. There isn't much you can't do to them to fill any need or wanton desire.

Burt Gummer

Active Member
May 18, 2009
Williamson County
The Mini will cost you a few hundred less but it will most likely be less accurate. I am a fan of the AR platform because magazines are cheap and accessories are plentiful.

AR would be $900-1100, mini 14 would be $675-750.

Get the AR 15.


Oct 27, 2008
The AR has a ton more options available, quality mags are more easily found, parts are more easily found, etc....

That said, the mini is a nice rifle.

Decide what you want the rifle for and go from there.

I really like the looks of the mini with a wood stock and the simplicity of it, though either are very nice.


May 17, 2009
Fort Worth
AR-15 all the way. I would say something in support of it, but everyone else already did that.
Top Bottom