Patriot Mobile

One Hand Gun Manipulation With Either Hand

The #1 community for Gun Owners in Texas

Member Benefits:

  • Fewer Ads!
  • Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership
  • Discuss anti-gun legislation
  • Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section
  • Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses
  • Discover free outdoor shooting areas
  • View up to date on firearm-related events
  • Share photos & video with other members
  • ...and so much more!
  • Paul Gomez

    Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 7, 2012
    51
    1
    Knoxville, TN
    I've been a proponent of learning to work the pistol with one hand for a long time. Why? Of course, the obvious answer is Injury to one hand. Another, less obvious, but more common occurrence is situations where one hand is being used to perform a task such as opening a door or controlling/guiding someone.
    Another aspect is confidence. Simply put, if you are confident manipulating the gun with your offhand, everything else is easy.


    The basic gun skills are the same regardless of how many hands you get to use. They are Drawing, Shooting, Reloading and Addressing Stoppages.





     

    Paul Gomez

    Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 7, 2012
    51
    1
    Knoxville, TN
    You are welcome, Mic. I've been offline for a bit as I was down in Bastrop teaching my RPM class this past weekend. In that one, we do a bunch of one handed gun work like this. It's pretty awesome to watch the vast amount of improvement that folks exhibit with a relatively minor time investment.
     

    tussery

    Active Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jul 26, 2008
    691
    21
    Corpus Christi
    I notice you say don't rely on the slide release as it creates a problem when you only have your weak hand. What if you run a gun say like a P30 would you train differently?
     

    Paul Gomez

    Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 7, 2012
    51
    1
    Knoxville, TN
    While some guns are designed to be ambidextrous, I am always leery of a technique that is gun-specific. My tendency is to stick with a simple protocol that can be applied to a wide range of guns.
     

    M. Sage

    TGT Addict
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 21, 2009
    16,298
    21
    San Antonio
    I agree with your other reason for not using the slide stop, too. Having a common solution for multiple problems can cut down on the decision making process, which will save time. The last thing you need under pressure is to stand there trying to remember how that flow chart went...
     

    Paul Gomez

    Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 7, 2012
    51
    1
    Knoxville, TN
    Skate board tape is a good short term solution but it will need to be replaced on a regular basis and there is the issue with the tape slipping on the slide and causing other issues.

    If the sights on your gun don't support manipulating it off of the belt, there are work-arounds, but they are all suboptimal. Using the edge of the ejection port may be viable off of the holster or a boot heel or something in the environment but, most of the time, it won't work off of the belt. This necessitates the use of a weaker position [such as when using a behind the hip holster] or taking a knee, etc.

    Part of setting up a gun for defensive use ought to be ensuring that the sights on the gun support manipulating the slide one handed.

    Here's an article that I wrote awhile back on this topic.

    Some Thoughts on Setting up a Defensive Pistol,as it Relates to 1 Hand Gun Work

    If you look at the gunhandling skills commonly taught, the most time-consuming, the most demanding, manipulation has to be those concerned with fixing a 'double feed'. Solving this problem is sometimes referred to as 'Remedial Action' because it is not resolved by applying 'Immediate Action', or 'Tap, Rack, etc'


    The classic process for addressing the 'double feed' consists of Lock, Rip, Work, Tap, Rack, Bang.


    First, we Lock the slide to the rear to remove the spring tension of the partially compressed recoil spring attempting to return the slide to its' forward position. Next, we Rip the magazine from the weapon, removing the ammunition source, allowing the slide to return fully forward. We work the slide fully forward and rearward to maximize the likelihood of extracting & ejecting the round/brass from the chamber. This manipulation is generally repeated three times. Having cleared the chamber, we fully insert a fresh magazine into the gun [Tap], Rack the slide to chamber a round from the new mag and shoot as indicated by our reassessment of the problem.


    A number of years ago a simplified remedial action drill began to make the rounds. There were several variations being put forth with the common theme of skipping the Lock phase and beginning your remedial action by forcefully ripping the mag from the gun. Some guys were teaching that you pull the mag just enough to allow the slide to close, without removing the mag from the mag well, reinsert the mag and continue shooting. This looked very cool & slick but one problem was that, often enough, the top round in the mag would dislodge and become trapped inside the mag well between the closed slide and the magazine. This prevented the mag from being seated, one round could be fired [assuming that the round in the chamber was, in fact, a live round...not normally the case with a spontaneously occurring double feed] and then caused a new stoppage as the loose round wound up in the path of the slide in some odd position. Another variation had the shooter rip the mag completely out of the gun, which allowed the slide to move forward, then reinserted and firing continued. Again, the huge assumption that the round in the chamber was a good one persisted.


    Generally, when you have a 'double feed', what you have is a Failure to Extract. In other words, Gun Went Bang and when the slide began moving rearward the extractor failed to remove the fired brass from the chamber. As the slide begins to return to its fully forward position, it attempts to feed a new round from the magazine. Since the empty brass wasn't pulled out & thrown away, the new round can't make it into the chamber. If all you do is remove the magazine, allowing to slide to close, you haven't actually got a live round into the chamber. You've gotten the slide closed, a piece of fired brass in the chamber and live ammo in the magazine.


    The short format Remedial Action that I have settled on consists of Rip, Work, Tap, Rack.


    First, we Rip the magazine completely out of the weapon. Next, Work the action fully Twice. When working with live ammo or dummy rounds, the stoppage sorts itself easily. When a double feed occurs unexpectedly, very often the round in the chamber is much more solidly in place and may require more work to remove. Letting the slide slam forward the first time will, hopefully, allow the extractor to snap over the cartridge rim. Pulling the slide all the way to the rear, allowing extraction & ejection, is the next step and it is repeated to maximize the likelihood of successfully clearing the chamber prior to insertion of the new magazine. Mag is seated [tap], Slide is Racked.


    One Hand gun work is every bit as vital, if not more so, than two hand gun work. We should strive to be as competent with either hand as we are when utilizing both hands. Just as we work right and left hand drawstroke, we should work left and right hand reloads, Immediate Action [Tap, Rack] and Remedial Action. I've written elsewhere about the need for sights that support one hand slide manipulation [metal sights rigidly mounted to the gun & the front face of the rear sight maintaining a 90-degree relationship to the slide].


    Now I'll talk about magazine &/or gun design that supports dealing with Remedial Action. If you look at the magazines originally supplied with the S&W M&P pistols, you will see an example of a magazine baseplate that does support the technique. The wide baseplate provides a lip that you can readily hook on a belt to rip the mag out of the gun.


    3435527474_5981a5050b.jpg



    If you look at a factory Glock mag, this is not the case. There is very little space around the bottom of the grip and the magazine baseplate on a Glock 17 or 19. If you insert a Glock 17 mag into a 19, suddenly you have a lot of real estate to work with. Of course, this increases the footprint of the package and a lot of guys will complain about this. Another option is to remove the thin sidewalls/plastic bevel on the bottom of the grip. This will result in exposing somewhere between ¼ and ½ inch more of the bottom of the magazine, allowing the shooter to hook the lip of the baseplate and rip the mag out of the gun.


    Glock 19 with mag well mod & current production mag in place


    3434721711_043667da72.jpg



    Glock 19 with mag well mod & Glock 17 mag in place


    3434721783_1e98ba73b3.jpg



    Some people have said, “How important is it to be able to clear a double feed one hand only?” Granted, it is a very unlikely situation. For most of us, having to use a firearm defensively is a very unlikely situation. That doesn't mean we should ignore that potentiality. If you set up your gear so that it supports an unlikely, but vitally important should you find yourself in need of it, skillset AND it has no negative impact on your primary skillset, why would you opt to not do so?


    In the grand old days, Jeff Cooper opined that a defensive pistol needed to be Reliable, have Sights that you could use at speed, a Trigger that you could manage and a Dehorn job so that the gun was not uncomfortable to handle.


    I'd modify that slightly by saying that the sights also must support one hand gun use and the mag/grip interface must also support one hand gun work.
     

    Paul Gomez

    Member
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jan 7, 2012
    51
    1
    Knoxville, TN
    The pictures in the previous post are, obviously, very crude. That was the first attempt working these ideas and it was done with a Spyderco in the parking lot of a Chik Fil A. The pistol featured in the video is a greatly refined example. You'll also see a modified OD frame Glock 19 in the Tactical Response Advanced Fighting Pistol DVD. I do not cover this material in that DVD but James & I do discuss the modification.
     
    Top Bottom