But black is the scary color.If it's for concealed carry, what does the color matter? It could be pink and no one's gonna see it unless things get ugly.
Go with whatever you like. If you're undecided, go with the rare color in case you decide to sell it later. Limited edition type stuff can sometimes bring more value down the road. Not gonna make you rich, but an extra $20 - $50 might be nice if the demand is there. If it's not, then no loss.