The breakup of the United States? Opportunity?

Discussion in 'News Articles' started by ambidextrous1, Nov 25, 2008.

  1. ambidextrous1

    ambidextrous1 Member

    This evening it was announced that Russian political analyst Igor Panarian has predicted that the current U.S. economic crisis will result in the breakup of the United States as a single sovereign nation.

    Personally, I think he's wrong; but let's think about what could happen, and what we'd like to see. Would Texas "go it alone", or carefully form alliances with neighboring States? Think about econonic, political, cultural, and military advantages and drawbacks.

    Think long and hard before you respond; there's no time limit. Consider this to be your only opportunity in this lifetime to "form a more perfect Union".:headscratch:
     


  2. Texan2

    Texan2 TGT Addict

    7,952
    0
    36
    Nov 8, 2008
    South of San Antonio
    We tried this in 1861...didn't turn out so good for Texas.

    Washington would never allow it to happen....never!
     
  3. djspump2003

    djspump2003 Active Member

    268
    1
    16
    Oct 19, 2008
    Austin
    The cop is right - state's rights was what the Civil War was all about.

    There have been a few books written about the subject. The overall conclusion seemed to be that we have let our government usurp way too much power from the people to let another Civil War occur. You add the overwhelming technological advantage that the feds have at their fingertips - satellite coverage for example - and dammit, they have Jack Bauer. Nuff said.

    I admit that it is a fun thought to entertain, but an impossibility that we must accept.

    The Russians planted the seeds back in the 1960's and look what they have grown into. They were such brilliant social engineers - using the freedoms of this country to ultimately destroy it. They just didn't realize it would take as long as it has.
     
  4. Texan2

    Texan2 TGT Addict

    7,952
    0
    36
    Nov 8, 2008
    South of San Antonio
    Well said!!! :texas:
     
  5. jim t

    jim t Member

    146
    0
    16
    Mar 4, 2008
    Hawley Texas
    although I dont think it will happen, dont forget texas isnt the undeveoped back water it was in the civilwar. we have the capacity to make our own weapons and supplies. it wont be so easy to take us now. no they are bigger well it depends on who is with us. but they have more of the sheeple than we do. too many ainty gun ainty war, tree huggers. we got the good ole boys who know how to use the guns we have. but it wont happen until they change more of us into the ainties.
     
  6. Texan2

    Texan2 TGT Addict

    7,952
    0
    36
    Nov 8, 2008
    South of San Antonio
    Lets make this hypothetical...

    Texas (at this point) does not have the capacity to manufacture enough arms to keep an army fighting.

    Does not have the capacity to make enough planes or sattelites or tanks or anything else.

    Now this is coming from someone who has traced his ancestry back and had kin folks fighting for the Confederacy.

    During the 1st Civil War, the South thought that because they were "raised in the woods" and knew how to shoot, they could overcome incredible odds against them. Didn't work then, wouldn't work now.

    I admire the pride, but dont let it get in the way of logic.

    It may work in the short run, but in the long run, the people in our society dont have the stomach or determination for an extended guerilla type conflict against other Americans.

    Lets hope we dont live to ever see another shooting war between Americans.
     
  7. Texas1911

    Texas1911 TGT Addict

    May 29, 2017
    Austin, TX
    Won't happen, because unlike the Soviet empire, we weren't a bunch of independent countries with independent governments, languages, cultures, etc. We are far more rooted in Americanism than the Soviets understand.

    Needless to say, the main reason it won't happen is because the average American doesn't want anything to change, and isn't going to actually do anything to change.
     
  8. oldguy

    oldguy Well-Known

    1,787
    0
    36
    Mar 6, 2008
    Quote(
    Won't happen, because unlike the Soviet empire, we weren't a bunch of independent countries with independent governments, languages, cultures, etc. We are far more rooted in Americanism than the Soviets understand.

    Needless to say, the main reason it won't happen is because the average American doesn't want anything to change, and isn't going to actually do anything to change.)Quote


    One thing I've learned in old age never say never, while we are not exactly like the Soviets we are becoming a fragmented country over
    300 million pop. with a third foreign born. We continue to raise/import a less patriotic less educated population each year.

    Your correct as long as we have it easy no one will fight but even a beagle pushed into a corner will bite and I believe Americans at some point in the future will reach the breaking point with our current path of outsourcing, loss of manufacturing,nation building, greed and lack of morals on Wall Street and government will in time cause our demise from that point all bets are off.

    We may still have time to fix the problems however I do not see how that could be achieved with our current election process perhaps term limits would be a great start.
     
  9. Moezilla

    Moezilla Member

    58
    0
    6
    Aug 9, 2008
    Allen
    I wouldn't be shocked to see this happen. There' already a deep ideological division within this country, whether people want to admit it or not, that is headed towards a breaking point. That breaking point would be the collapse of the economic foundation that holds us together. If the economy were to collapse, it would cause people to turn to their state governments for leadership when they realized the federal leadership has failed. The Feds would try to wrest control from the states to sustain their power, not the country, which would lead to rebellion. It would be a real world SHTF scenario and the scary part is, this is looking more and more like a real scenario that could develop rather than some mental wargaming.
     
  10. TAZ

    TAZ Active Member

    853
    33
    48
    Oct 17, 2008
    Round Rock
    As mich as I would like to think it possible to wrest control away from the feds, it just isnt a reality at this time. Some great implosion would have to happen to the feds for any chance at it. An economic desaster would not be enough, much like it wasnt enough during the Great Depression. Any such economic disaster would consolidate power even more.

    Whetehr we like to accept it or not, we live in a global world. The kind of "disaster" that would enable the states to break free would have HUGE world wide implications. Implications big enough to suggest that the states would be much better off pooling resources as a nation rather than go at it alone.
     

Share This Page