Oxfords or brogues?
Now heres a subject that could take up 200 pages worth of bandwidth and start a civil war.
A good oxford is an adequately acceptable shoe choice for most. Brogues! Now that screams sophisticated and timeless. So no brogues do no scream old geezer, rather they scream class, eternal and style. Not everyone can pull off brogues. Especially the multi color examples. If you gotta ask why...well you'll never be capable of understanding it in the first place.
Full brogue........