tripp vs wilson mags

DCortez

TGT Addict
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Jan 28, 2009
6,597
36
Houston, Cy-Fair
I'm looking to buy several mags ... so ... Tripp or Wilson mags ftw? (For The Win for you non-gaming noobs).


I have several Wilson Combat mags, the $30-$35 variety, think they are okay but not great. Am I missing something?


Did a search, blah blah blah ....
 

40Arpent

TGT Addict
TGT Supporter
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Jul 16, 2008
7,063
48
Houston
I have no experience with Tripp mags, but have heard nothing but good things about them. I have plenty of experience with Wilson 47D magazines, and have nothing but good things to say about them.
 

JKTex

Well-Known
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Mar 11, 2008
2,011
38
DFW, North Texas
I think Wilson, while good mags, better than the average, are over rated. I think the Wilson name carries them. That said, they seem to stand behind the mags and fix or replace them easily.

Tripp however, seems to be the 1 mag that people use without question for duty, when they have to count on a mag.

I think the key is Virgil's follower and springs. I've got several Tripp kits in other mag tubes they they work flawlessly. Wilson's follower is similar but with all plastic and no metal to lock. Wilson's springs are know to sometimes be weak, even out of the package. They replace them, but shouldn't have to.

To go a step further, I know a few people, including a certain high end, very experienced custom builder that swear by CMC Power Mags with Tripp kits. It's felt that the CMC tubes and Tripp innerds are bullet-proof and will last forever.

BTW, Tripp is also incredible when it comes to help with his mags. Just call.

That said, I don't have any Wilson mags and don't think I ever will. Tripp and Tripp kits in other tubes have been 100% reliable for me.
 

DCortez

TGT Addict
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Jan 28, 2009
6,597
36
Houston, Cy-Fair
If Kimber puts their name on it, it should be worthy, and they are not. Kind of like putting an 8-track in a new corvette.


Anyway ... I'll try a few tripps and report back. The Wilsons seemed okay, but I didn't hear the cat's meow.
 

JKTex

Well-Known
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Mar 11, 2008
2,011
38
DFW, North Texas
I hate to run off track here, but isn't that line of thinking a bit counter to your defense of crappy mags supplied by Kimber?

Not at all.

Kimber makes, markets and sells 1911's and tosses a magazine in with. Most of the time the mag. works fine. Like tires on new cars. I usually buy new/good tires as soon as I take delivery. OEM tires aren't the same as what you buy on the street; sometimes they're fine, sometimes their crap.

Wilson on the other hand, makes, markets and sells magazines they claim to be superior to everything else as well as contain parts (follower) designed and made by them for their mags. You should not buy a premium magazine for $30+ and have to have them replace it or send a new spring for it before it works. It's not a complex piece of equipment. But it happens a lot. You don't hear that about Tripp, or even CMC.

BTW, the CMC Powermags come with the split followers which work fine for most people. I don't care for them, and with some, the follower to tilt forward which in some alum. frame guns makes a mess of the frame.

It's not cheap to buy a Powermags ($25 - $28 or so I think) then the Tripp kit ($9 each) but people swear by them. A guy on another board just sold off some her built up from new parts, then had the tubes finished in (can't recall) so he had about $45 in each mag, but they never failed. For duty maybe, but that's a little overboard I think.
 

DCortez

TGT Addict
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Jan 28, 2009
6,597
36
Houston, Cy-Fair
I just tried to order some Tripp mags. The check out is either bugged or there is no longer a quantity discount. "Contact Us" portion of the site, formmail.com, times out immediately.


Oh well....



EDIT: almost bought Kimber tac-mags but couldn't bring myself to click through ... I'll call Tripp tomorrow ... LOL
 

JKTex

Well-Known
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Mar 11, 2008
2,011
38
DFW, North Texas
I just tried to order some Tripp mags. The check out is either bugged or there is no longer a quantity discount. "Contact Us" portion of the site, formmail.com, times out immediately.


Oh well....



EDIT: almost bought Kimber tac-mags but couldn't bring myself to click through ... I'll call Tripp tomorrow ... LOL

Ya I'd try again later or call. It's a pretty basic plain-Jane site but has always worked fine for me.

And I like buying from fellow Texan's.
 

Support

Sponsors

Greeneye Tactical
silencers
third coast
DK Firearms
Tyrant Designs
Ranier
Every Day Man
Shroud
Shroud

Forum statistics

Threads
101,449
Messages
2,337,374
Members
31,874
Latest member
Binkley
Top Bottom